GEICO Settlement Offers and Maximizing Your Accident Payoff

This page aims to help you understand the settlement value of your case against GEICO and give you weapons to maximize the settlement value of your claim. Learn the secrets they don’t want you to know and get the most money you can from your claim. This page is focused on claims against GEICO in Baltimore, Maryland, and the surrounding area. But most of what you will learn will apply in any state in the country.

GEICO

In 1936, GEICO was initially created to provide auto insurance to government employees and military personnel. Over the years, the company expanded its customer base and now offers insurance coverage to a broader audience.

GEICO is owned by Berkshire Hathaway, a corporate conglomerate that owns numerous subsidiary companies and brands, including Duracell, Diary Queen, Long & Foster, and others. GEICO provides many insurance products, but auto insurance is this insurer’s primary focus and the most significant portion of its business.

GEICO Claims

GEICO is a difficult insurance company to deal with. If you have not figured that out yet, you will. If you are trying to maximize the settlement value of your personal injury claim in Maryland, you want to have every weapon you can to understand the true value of your case. Will GEICO try to pay you less than the value of your car accident claim? They absolutely will. So, you have to be prepared for battle in personal injury cases. This page can be a resource to help you better understand how GEICO values and defends accident claims.

What you need to know about GEICO is that this insurer softens up the deeper you get into the process. GEICO rarely offers a fair settlement offer before trial.

If you have a claim against GEICO or a GEICO insured in Maryland or Washington, D.C., call us at 800-553-8082 for a free consultation or fill out this free case review form today.

Are you here with specific questions about your GEICO claim? Our lawyers have created shortcuts if you have a particular topic of interest:

Determining the Settlement Payout of Your GEICO Claim

GEICO does not have a standard formula that they use to calculate damages. The starting point of understanding the value of your case against GEICO has nothing to do with GEICO. It starts with your injury. The nature and severity of your injury will dictate the potential value of your claim with GEICO. We provide statistics and sample cases based on your type of injury. Read what our personal injury lawyers have written about the value of auto accident cases here.

How Much Should You Expect For GEICO’s First Settlement Offer?

Elsewhere on this website, we offer information about the settlement value of car and truck accident claims. We also provide examples of settlements and verdicts that our firm and other lawyers have had in cases against GEICO. But those are “end of the day” answers. Many victims want to figure out something far more immediate: how much of a first settlement offer can I expect from GEICO?

GEICO tends to make extremely low first settlement offers. At Miller & Zois, we reviewed some old files to show victims how much money GEICO offered compared to the client’s medical expenses. We pulled some random first settlement offers in car accident cases along with the amount of the client’s medical bills to give you some idea of what you might be able to expect. We do not think this kind of data is available anywhere else. We have looked everywhere ourselves to find something similar.

Remember, these are the first settlement offers and the amount of claimed medical bills.

*Indicates policy limits offer

What Does This First Settlement Offer Data Tell Us?

First, let’s talk about what our attorneys have done here. We have pulled cases largely at random of auto accident cases that Miller & Zois has had with GEICO in recent years. Our lawyers are not providing in this chart any relevant facts about the type of injury, the crash itself, lost wages, or other factors—almost every vital fact you would want to know about the case to value it properly and what a reasonable payout would be.

So why do these statistics have any meaning at all? Well, when you throw out the outliers, GEICO has a pretty predictable pain and suffering calculator. GEICO’s initial settlement offers are usually no more than 20% of the total medical expenses. In many cases, GEICO’s initial lowball offer is even less than the claimed medical expenses. The GEICO insurance adjuster’s first offer generally falls into one of three categories:

1. Low
2. Crazy low
3. The definition of bad faith

Considering this data on GEICO’s initial settlement offers in conjunction with sample verdicts and settlements in similar cases, you can pin down a possible value range for your case. But remember how impossible it is to conclude anything based on this evidence alone as to the actual value of your case. Too many variables are involved in placing a settlement value on a car accident claim in Maryland. But it tells you something about the value of your case in relative terms.

Filing a Lawsuit in GEICO Insurance Claims

You must file a lawsuit against GEICO’s insured if you want a fair, reasonable settlement offer on a car accident claim. Every claims adjuster will blink a bit when a suit is filed. A GEICO adjuster blinks even more than most. GEICO usually changes insurance adjusters when a lawsuit is filed, and the new adjuster promptly throws the old one under the bus and says the claim was undervalued. Settlement offers from GEICO tend to increase dramatically after a lawsuit is filed. Our lawyers prefer to file suit in almost all of our GEICO accident cases involving significant injuries. We don’t file suit in every GEICO case because some of our clients want to avoid litigation.

Despite their tendency to undervalue claims, GEICO is not some evil empire. In fact, dealing with GEICO claim adjusters is a pleasant experience. They are particularly easy to work with in terms of their disposition and willingness to promptly return calls as far as insurance companies go.  You do not have to wait long for a GEICO settlement check if you do agree on the payout. Really, we only disagree with the company on one issue: the settlement check our clients should receive in personal injury cases in the Baltimore/Washington area. But the amount of the payout is what every personal injury case is really about.

The settlement compensation for an injury case is what motor vehicle accident claims are all about. The civil justice system is about giving money to compensate victims for the harm that is done to them. Our job is to fight for our clients to get as much money in their pocket as humanly possible. More often than not, if the client’s goal is to get every last penny they are entitled to get, then a lawsuit is the most sensible option.

Our lawyers have won literally millions of dollars in settlements and verdicts against GEICO. If you need someone on your side who knows how to fight this insurance company and win, call 800-553-8082 or get a free online consultation.

Settlements and Verdicts Against GEICO in Maryland

There is also  value in looking at other cases against GEICO. Below is a small sampling of Miller & Zois cases involving GEICO that we compiled a few years ago. These results do not necessarily reflect the value of your claim.  Why?  There are too many variables at play when looking at the value of a car accident case to fit in a summary of the case. Still, we think these verdict and settlement stories are informative to help you better understand settlement compensation payouts in car accident claims against GEICO.

• Maryland 2024: $847,431 Verdict. The plaintiff was stopped at a traffic light when she was rear-ended by the defendant, who was intoxicated at the time of the accident. The plaintiff claimed she suffered injuries to her head, and cervical and lumbar spine. She further alleged she suffered a concussion, post-concussion syndrome, a traumatic brain injury, convergency insufficiency, and post-traumatic narcolepsy. The defendant was undersinured, so she sought damages under her UIM coverage with GEICO. GEICO disputed the injuries and took the case to trial. A Montgomery County jury awarded $847,431.
• Maryland 2023: $139,817 Verdict. The plaintiff asserted was stopped at a red traffic light when he was rear-ended by a vehicle operated by the defendant, an underinsured motorist. The plaintiff suffered injuries to his cervical, lumbar, and thoracic spine; left arm and wrist; left trapezius muscle; face and jaw including displacement of the right condylar head and right temporal tendonitis; and headaches. The defendant’s insurance company refused to offer policy limits and the plaintiff’s UIM carrier, GEICO also denied the plaintiff’s claim.
• Maryland 2022: $7,500 Verdict. The plaintiff allegedly suffered a loss of consciousness and an altered mental status, post-concussive/post-traumatic head syndrome with cognitive impairment, tinnitus, exacerbation of migraines and irritability, and major neurocognitive disorder due to traumatic brain injury. She settled for policy limits with the at-fault driver and sought UIM damages from GEICO.
• Maryland 2021: $30,000 Verdict. The plaintiff, an adult female, said she was riding as a passenger in her mother’s vehicle when the vehicle stopped. While stopped, the plaintiff’s host vehicle was rear-ended by a vehicle driven by the defendant. At the time of the collision, the plaintiff was covered by an automobile insurance policy issued by defendant GEICO, which included underinsured motorist benefits.
  The plaintiff filed a complaint against the defendants, alleging the defendant’s negligent driving caused the collision and GEICO breached the terms of the insurance contract by failing to pay underinsured motorist benefits.
• Maryland 2020: $180,000 Settlement. Our client is heading eastbound on Norbeck Road in Montgomery County. A Dodge Ram pick-up truck traveling westbound erratically veers off on the shoulder and then crosses the center line. He hits our client head-on. The property damages is lighter than you would expect. But our client suffers a Lisfranc fracture, a foot injury our law firm has seen many times. The police report suggests the erratic behavior might result from drinking while driving. Our lawyers file suit in most claims against GEICO like this. But we were able to settle this case out-of-court without filing a lawsuit with an insurance adjuster working at home during the COVID-19 quarantine.
• Maryland 2019: $300,000 Settlement. Our client was heading home and sitting on the ramp to merge onto University Boulevard from Route 495 in Montgomery County. She was hit in the rear while patiently waiting for a break in traffic. She did not seem very hurt at first, but she still drove herself to the emergency room. She was ultimately diagnosed with a disc injury in her back and had anterior lumbar fusion surgery. GEICO made a lousy settlement offer, which was partially understandable because the injury was preexisting. But we marshaled our medical experts and pain and suffering witnesses and convinced GEICO to settle the case for $300,000 at a mediation.
• Maryland, 2019: $200,000 Settlement Our client is rear-ended in a Prince George’s County car accident. The property damage is not significant, and he does not have any injuries that he considers to be serious at the time. But the injuries do not resolve. We demand $55,000—our client is not looking for that much. Allstate offers $17,076.68 which really was not a good faith offer. Our firm files suit in Circuit Court against Allstate and also against GEICO for underinsured motorist coverage. The at-fault driver only has a $100,000 policy. Allstate increases the offer to $37,200 just before trial. This is another case where Allstate and GEICO’s pain and suffering calculators just does not translate to real human beings.  The trial begins and this becomes readily apparent.  We destroy their expert on the stand. While our client’s wife is offering pain and suffering testimony, GEICO and Allstate says they want to talk settlement. Our original offer to settle is now long off the table. The insurers offered $175,000. We said it is $200,000 or we continue the trial. So they agreed to $200,000 ($100,000 each). The case settles in the middle of the trial.
• Maryland, 2019: $300,000 Settlement Our client is a passenger in a friend’s car in Baltimore County. The driver hits a light pole to avoid an animal on the road. He is diagnosed at Northwest Hospital with a neck, strain, and wrist sprain. He is discharged with pain medicine. He gets a cervical steroid injection that provides only temporary relief. Ultimately, he has a discectomy and fusion and (eventually) has a remarkable recovery.
• Maryland, 2018: $250,000 Settlement Our client, a 45-year-old woman, is traveling on Route 97 in Anne Arundel County. She stops in heavy traffic and is rear-ended. The police are not called to the scene because she does not initially believe she is seriously injured. She sustains $5300 in property damage to her vehicle. Her medical records show degeneration at C4-C5 that was injured in a prior accident (she had a prior neck fusion). These pre-existing injury cases are always more challenging but that does not mean the victim cannot prevail. Ultimately, she receives nerve block injections. GEICO tenders their $100,000 insurance policy and she receives $150,000 from her own insurance carrier on her underinsured motorist claim. Miller & Zois handled this claim.
• Maryland (Baltimore), 2018: $100,000 Settlement A 13-year-old boy walks down the sidewalk when a motorcycle takes a left turn in front of a car at Kenwood Avenue and Dale Avenue in Baltimore City. The bike flies over the hood and lands on the boy, breaking his leg. GEICO tenders its $100,000 policy before a lawsuit is filed. Miller & Zois handled this claim.
• Maryland, 2018: $200,000 Settlement An elderly man exits his car to cross the street in Baltimore. He is struck and killed by the defendant. There is no good evidence as to where the man was hit and killed although he clearly was not in a crosswalk. This was our problem: there was no proof either way, and the Plaintiff bore the burden of proof. Defendant files a motion to dismiss the case but agrees to settle for $200,000 before the motion is heard. Would we have lost the motion? Probably. But this underscores the value of having a good personal injury lawyer that the insurance company fears.
• Maryland, 2018: $290,000 Settlement A 40-year-old woman suffers an L-5-disc injury after a double impact, chain reaction, rear-end accident. She has a negative MRI but has a discectomy that reveals nerve damage. The pre-suit offer is $70,000. Miller & Zois handled this case.
• Maryland, 2018: $340,000 Verdict Plaintiff suffers head (mild TBI) and disc injuries in a left turn accident case that is tried in Prince George’s County. The offer at the pre-trial conference is zero. GEICO’s policy is $250,000, but the uninsured motorist carrier agrees before the trial not to seek subrogation from GEICO’s insured if the verdict exceeds the policy limits which, thankfully, is exactly what happens. Miller & Zois handled this case.
• Maryland, 2018: $170,000 Settlement Plaintiff is driving on Route 97 in Carroll County when he approaches a non-functional traffic light. Defendant does not realize the light is not working and runs through it. Defendants contend that Plaintiff was contributorily negligent for failing to proceed with care through a broken traffic light. The plaintiff has a broken left femur, ribs, various cuts and abrasions, and severely bruised feet. GEICO is the driver’s insurance company, and they tender their policy limits. The rest we recover from the uninsured motorist carrier (Cincinnati Insurance). Our law firm handled this claim.
• Maryland, 2018: $175,000 Settlement Our client is rear-ended on Route 4 in Calvert County. She goes to Urgent Care that evening, complaining of pain in her jaw, left shoulder, left neck, and lower back. She ultimately has a cervical diskectomy and fusion in her neck at C5-C6. We have no choice but to file suit because GEICO just will not make an offer.
• Maryland, 2018: $300,000 Settlement A man is stopped at a red light in Montgomery County and is rear-ended at a high rate of speed. He is flown to Prince George’s Hospital Center but does not survive. This wrongful death settlement is for the policy limits. An exhaustive search for assets of the defendant driver reveals that he had no significant assets and only a $15,000 Pennsylvania insurance policy. GEICO pays the remaining $285,000 in uninsured motorist benefits. Our law firm handled this case.

GEICO Settlements and Verdicts Outside of Maryland

• Washington 2024: $93,000 Verdict. The plaintiff was riding his motorcycle when the defendant attempted to pass him on a double-yellow line, into oncoming traffic. The defendant allegedly sideswiped the plaintiff’s motorcycle when crossing back into the lane after passing, causing the plaintiff to crash and suffer significant injuries, including a fractured arm, and fractured scapula. After settling with the defendant’s insurance company for policy limits ($30,000) the plaintiff’s UIM carrier, GEICO, denied his claim for additional damages and took the case to court.
• Virginia 2024: $20,000 Settlement. The plaintiff, a minor, was a passenger in a vehicle involved in a collision and suffered injuries. GEICO was the insurer and they initially denied liability, but eventually agreed to settle the claims and sought court approval of the settlement because it involved a minor.
• New Jersey 2023: $30,000 Settlement. Th plaintiff, a minor, was reportedly crossing the street when she was struck by a vehicle. The vehicle subsequently fled the scene.  Defendant GEICO Insurance Company had an unspecified involvement in the plaintiff’s potential claim.
  The plaintiff reportedly suffered injuries to the left knee.
• Washington 2023: $44,460 Verdict. The plaintiff was operating a vehicle southbound in the eastmost lane, approaching a traffic light. The defendant was also traveling southbound and in the lane to the right of P’s vehicle. The defendant allegedly made an illegal left turn from the second lane of traffic, the lane to the plaintiff’s right, and turned into the front passenger quarter panel of her vehicle. Bilateral hip, shoulder, neck, and upper back injuries. No permanency, and the plaintiff treated for approximately 21 months. GEICO refused to make a reasonable settlement offer and the case went to trial in Spokane County.
• New York 2023: $150,000 Settlement. The plaintiff, a 10-year-old boy, was a passenger in a vehicle operated by the defendant that came to a complete stop at an intersection and then proceeded to enter the intersection. The plaintiff said the vehicle he occupied was struck in the intersection on the driver’s side by a vehicle. The plaintiff allegedly suffered facial lacerations with facial scaring, TMJ, and disc herniations at L4-S1. GEICO made a policy limit settlement for $150,000.
• Alabama 2022: $75,000 Verdict. The plaintiff alleged that he was on a motorized scooter in a crosswalk in the parking lot of a Walmart store in Hazel Green, Alabama, when he was struck by a motor vehicle operated by the defendant. Plaintiff claimed that he suffered severe injuries, including an injury to his ribs on the right side, a collapsed right lung, and pain in his right arm. He brought a UIM claim against GEICO.
• New Jersey 2022: $7,000 Settlement. The plaintiff, an 11-year-old female, covered under a policy issued by defendant GEICO, allegedly suffered thoracic and lumbar sprain/strains and a right leg injury when the vehicle in which she was a passenger, stopped at a traffic light, was struck in the rear by a vehicle that had been struck in the rear by an uninsured motorist (UM).

GEICO Claim FAQ

Our experienced car accident lawyers have been dealing with GEICO for years. Below are questions our clients have had about their claims that you may also have.

Is Geico reasonable to deal with in accident claims?

Everyone likes Warren Buffett. This insurer also generally has very professional adjusters, many of which are easy to like. But here is the truth: GEICO is a very difficult insurer to deal with in accident claims, particularly before a lawsuit is filed. GEICO simply has a business model that aggressively focuses on settling claims for as little as possible. This model instructs them to try to resolve cases for far less than they are worth.

GEICO plays hardball and has bad faith claims to prove it.

Where is the GEICO adjuster handling my claim?

This insurer has regional claims centers. Most Maryland claims are processed in the Fredericksburg, Virginia office. GEICO adjusters are still working during the COVID-19 pandemic from their homes.

How does GEICO negotiate claims before a suit is filed?

GEICO only gives its adjusters a little authority before a lawsuit is filed. The claims rep will make you an offer that is some percentage of the adjuster’s power to settle the case.

This next part is essential. The gap between (1) the initial offer and the settlement authority and (2) the settlement authority and the real value of the case increases with the size of the case. Let’s make up an example that is pretty true to form. If a case has a trial value of $10,000, the adjuster might offer $4,000 with authority to go up to $5,500. But if the real value of the case is $500,000, this insurer might offer $125,000 with authority to go to $150,000.

Why are GEICO’s settlement offers so small?

To make the obscene profits GEICO has historically generated, the company tries to rip off victims on the value of their claim. That may be a harsh assessment, but it is the stark reality. Think about the math. GEICO spends $1 billion a year on advertising. It touts that you can save fifteen percent by spending only fifteen minutes switching to GEICO. The company also offers some customers “accident forgiveness,” so their insurance rates do not increase after an accident. GEICO plays hardball before a suit is filed, hoping to pay less than what the injury claim is worth. If you can rip off just 30% of the victims making claims, that is a lot of extra money for advertising and profits.

What happens after I file a lawsuit against GEICO?

Almost invariably, the offer increases. This is true with most insurance companies but is particularly true with GEICO. One reason for this: you get a new adjuster when a suit is filed. The new adjuster says, “Okay, the first adjuster was an idiot, let’s talk about the real value of this case.” All right, that is hyperbole. But it is not that far from the truth. Now, this number is also usually far less than the trial or settlement value of the case. But it is almost certainly well north of the value before a suit was filed and the new adjuster came aboard.

Will GEICO let my case go to trial or will they try to back down and settle the case before trial?

How bold GEICO is will depend on what the sticking point in the case is. If the dispute concerns liability—who caused the accident—this insurer will often stick to its guns. If the dispute is over how much money agreed upon injuries are worth, GEICO rarely lets these cases go to trial, at least in Maryland.

What will happen if I get a jury verdict that exceeds the policy limits?

There is no way to know. What any insurance company will do when a verdict exceeds the policy limits depends on the facts of the case. But if the plaintiff’s personal injury attorney makes a settlement demand for the policy limits or less, GEICO will often stand behind its insured and pay whatever the verdict is regardless of the policy limits.

The vehicles in my crash had very little property damage, but I was hurt. My doctors are willing to testify that I was severely hurt in the crash. Will GEICO ever come to its senses?

It is doubtful. Probably more than any other insurance company out there, Government Employees Insurance Company has an aversion to low and no property damage injury cases. So, there is a high probability that a case like that will go to trial if the victim wants to get something resembling fair value on the case.

Do I need a lawyer to handle my claim?

In general, you will be best protected by hiring counsel to represent your interests. If you are seriously injured in an accident, I think it is entirely foolish not to hire a lawyer. Good legal advice matters. That said, if you have a small case, the gap between what you can get for yourself and what a lawyer can get for you is narrower. Should you still hire a car accident lawyer in those small injury cases? I think you should. Is it crazy to handle these cases alone without a lawyer? No, and here is how you do it without a lawyer.

Who Are GEICO’s Lawyers and Experts in Maryland?

If you do file a lawsuit, most of the claims will be handled by Besok & Mullen or John Dahut & Associates. These personal injury defense law firms have “law firm names.” But they are not law firms in the traditional sense. There are in-house counsel and employees of the insurer. This is done to cut down on the company’s legal fees. On balance, these lawyers are far more reasonable than the claims adjusters when placing a fair settlement value on accident claims.

GEICO refers out some cases when they are concerned that there is a real chance the verdict could exceed the defendant’s insurance policy limits. The Law Offices of Frank Daily—a good group of car accident lawyers—is one of the firms this insurer heavily relies upon in these cases in Baltimore. It often uses Mulhern & Patterson in cases in Maryland/D.C. suburbs.

This insurance company has many “usual suspect” experts in defending their positions that the Plaintiff is either not hurt or not hurt as bad as the Plaintiff suggests. If it is an orthopedics case, as many car crash injuries are, the insurer frequently refers to

• Dr. Joel Falik
• Dr. Louis S. Halikman
• Dr. J. Richard Wells, Jr.
• Dr. Eddie Cohen
• Dr. Gary London (neurologist)
• Dr. Clifford Hinkes
• Charles Citrin (neuroradiologist)
• James Gasho

GEICO regularly names these same witnesses in an incredible amount of motor vehicle accident cases in Maryland and the District of Columbia. What is incredible is that GEICO lawyers often name these experts long before the doctors have heard the patient’s name or seen a single medical record. What does this mean? They seem confident that these experts will say what they want them to say.

What states does GEICO cover?

GEICO writes consumer auto insurance in all 50 U.S. states (and D.C.), and it is one of the largest auto insurers in the country. GEICO is the largest insurer in Maryland and Washington, DC.

How does GEICO pay claims?

GEICO will pay your claim either by sending a check to you (or your attorney) or by submitting direct payment to an approved auto repair shop.

How much will my GEICO insurance increase after a speeding ticket?

A speeding ticket will increase your GEICO insurance premium by an average of 19%. This places GEICO in the middle of the pack in terms of premium increases for speeding tickets, with the highest average being 34% and the lowest at 7%.

How do I report an accident to GEICO?

GEICO offers multiple ways to submit an auto accident claim: (1) file your claim online, (2) file your claim on your phone using the GEICO mobile app; or (3) call GEICO 24 hours a day at 800-841-3000.

What happens to auto loans if GEICO totals my car?

If your vehicle is totaled GEICO will pay the fair market value. If you have a loan on the vehicle, GEICO will pay off the existing balance on that auto loan before paying anything to you.

Contacting GEICO for an Injury Claim

To contact this insurer in a Maryland case, you can reach them at:

GEICO Direct
P.O Box 9505
Fredericksburg, VA 22403
The best number is 1-800-841-1003.

Keep in mind the risks associated with talking to the insurance company without counsel.

Getting a Weapon to Fight GEICO

Our accident lawyers at Miller & Zois have handled hundreds of personal injury claims against GEICO and have helped many people get the money they deserve for their injuries. If you have been injured in a motor vehicle accident in Maryland and GEICO insures the at-fault driver, or if you are filing an uninsured motorist claim against GEICO, and you have a question about your personal injury claim, call us at 800-553-8082 for a free consultation or fill out this brief online claim evaluation form.