Rental car accidents are common. People are driving in areas that are not familiar with cars that are not familiar. Rental car crashes can often lead to a complex series of claims and procedures.
The good news for accident victims is that there tends to be more insurance coverage in rental car accidents than in your typical car crash claim because there are often multiple types of insurance available. This page looks at settlement and verdicts payouts in rental car accident cases.
The Cause of Rental Car Accidents
People crash rental cars because the driver is driving a different car. Take your own car for example. Chances are you have a feel for its capabilities, limitations, and handling characteristics. When you hop into a rental car, you do not have this level of familiarity, which can lead to an accident if the driver does not take the time to acclimatize to the new vehicle.
Another contributing factor is how drivers are generally unfamiliar with the area in which they are driving their rental car. We all grow accustomed to the various eccentricities of certain turns, intersections, and roads that are close to home. But unfamiliarity with an area usually means fumbling with maps, GPS, or staring at road signs when eyes should be on the road.
How the Rental Car Companies Deal With This
Rental car companies offer supplemental insurance for rental vehicles in light of how likely an accident is. Companies also tend to offer additional coverage, which is “insurance-like” but not necessarily insurance. While purchasing supplemental insurance is often a good idea, you should check your insurance policy beforehand. Your policy may offer supplemental coverage, the most common of which are referred to as 1) collision damage waiver (CDW); 2) supplemental liability protection (SLP); and 3) personal accident insurance (PAI).
The Complexities of Rental Car Accidents
Rental car accidents are more complex than your run-of-the-mill auto accident because of all the parties involved. While a typical car accident typically involves the drivers and their respective insurance companies, a rental car accident adds the rental car agency, supplemental insurance provider, and even the credit card company into the mix. Here is how each party can be involved:
- Your car insurance policy: More often than not, the at-fault driver’s car insurance policy will cover claims made while driving a rental car.
- The rental car company: The company maintains insurance on their rental fleet but whether that coverage applies depends on many complex factors.
- The credit card company: Credit card companies offer services to their users, and a surprisingly common service is insurance on rental cars that are paid for with a credit card. In a scenario where your personal insurance may cover a claim, the credit card may cover the deductible. (So it is generally a good idea to pay for a rental car with a credit card if the service is offered.)
- The supplemental insurance provider: If the at-fault driver purchased supplemental insurance, that is another possible pocket from which the victim can recover.
What do all of these players in the system mean? More complexity but more options for victims looking for insurance to pay for their injuries. This is where hiring an attorney pays off. Considering all of the various forces at work here, bringing in an experienced attorney is the only way to protect your rights. Doing so ensures that you have an advocate who can access all of these various facets of insurance, minimizing any financial obligation and maximizing the amount that you could potentially receive for a claim.
After a Rental Car Accident
If you’re involved in a rental car accident, treat it as you would any other vehicle accident. Prioritize safety by seeking medical attention if needed and calling the police to file a report. Exchange information with the other driver and take plenty of photos to document the damage. Once immediate concerns are addressed, contact the rental car agency to follow their procedures and notify your insurance company. If your credit card offers coverage for rental cars, reach out to them as well.
Before returning the rental car, make sure you have copies of all necessary documents, including the rental agreement and the accident report. These will be crucial for resolving any claims or disputes. Taking these steps ensures you’re compliant with the rental company’s requirements and prepared to handle any insurance-related matters.
The Graves Amendment
The Graves Amendment, also known as the Rental Car Liability Protection Act, is a key federal law in the United States that restricts the liability of rental car companies in accidents caused by their customers. Here’s an overview of its key aspects:
Function of the Graves Amendment
- Limits Vicarious Liability for Rental Companies: The law ensures rental companies are not automatically liable for accidents simply because they own the vehicle. Instead, the focus is on the driver’s negligence.
- Effective for Accidents Post-2005: It applies to accidents occurring after its enactment in 2005, not affecting prior incidents.
- Exceptions to the Rule: Rental companies can still face liability in certain situations, albeit rare, such as:
- Accidents due to mechanical failures from poor maintenance or repairs
- Renting to unqualified or unauthorized drivers
- Violations of other car rental regulations
For context, we have never seen or heard of a case from another auto accident attorney that falls under one of those exceptions. But they can happen.
Implications for Maryland Auto Accident Victims
The Graves Amendment just makes it harder on Maryland plaintiffs in a rental car accident, unfortunately. Here are some of the potential adverse consequences:
- Potential Need to Sue the Driver: Victims might have to target the driver, not the rental company, especially if the Graves Amendment is applicable. This could be challenging if the driver’s insurance is insufficient.
- Significance of Rental Insurance: It becomes more critical as it may cover gaps left by the driver’s insurance limitations or the application of the Graves Amendment.
- Complex Legal Landscape: Determining the applicability of the Graves Amendment and identifying liable parties requires a detailed legal examination of the accident’s circumstances.
Maryland car accident lawyers dislike the Graves Amendment because it offers significant limitations on the liability of rental car companies in the event of an accident. So with rental companies largely protected, car crash attorneys must often pursue claims against the individual drivers, who may have insufficient insurance coverage or personal assets to provide full compensation to our clients. This can result in lower settlement amounts or more challenging litigation processes.
Verdicts and Settlements in Rental Car Accident Cases
$90,000 Settlement (South Carolina 2024): The plaintiff, a minor, was a passenger in a rental vehicle driven by his grandmother that was involved in an accident. The at-fault driver had no insurance so the plaintiff sought damages under the UIM coverage of the Enterprise Rental company policy and his mother’s UIM policy. The settlement was split between Enterprise and the grandmother’s carrier.
$368,000 Verdict (Illinois 2024): The plaintiff, a 64-year-old woman, was walking toward her rental car in a parking lot operated by defendant Enterprise Leasing Company of Chicago. A customer service agent for Enterprise reversed the vehicle he was driving in the parking lot and struck her. The plaintiff reportedly suffered injuries, including a Lisfranc injury.
$100,468 Verdict (Washington 2024): The plaintiff, a 24-year-old female, was a passenger in the front seat of her boyfriend’s Toyota 4Runner rental car when they struck from behind after coming to a stop for traffic. The plaintiff suffered a torn labrum in her right shoulder which required multiple surgeries over the course of 2 years. She settled with the at-fault driver for policy limits of $100,000 and then brought this case for additional UIM damages.
$16,263 Verdict (Georgia 2023): The defendant rented a car from plaintiff Avis Rent a Car and declined to purchase loss damage waiver insurance. The defendant was driving the rental vehicle when she was struck by another driver who ran a red light. Avis Rental Car filed suit against the defendant and the at-fault driver seeking $15,000 for property damage to the rental vehicle. The jury awarded damages against both defendants.
$47,902 Verdict (Nevada 2022): The defendant was driving a rental car from Budget Rent A Car & Sales when he cross over three lanes of westbound traffic in an effort to make a right turn onto highway on-ramp. In the process of crossing over the lanes, the defendant forced the plaintiff off the road and into a raised island ramp causing him to suffer various unspecified injuries.
$1 Verdict (North Carolina 2021): The plaintiff was returning a rental car to Enterprise when the defendant who was also returning a rental car to the same facility, allegedly struck the plaintiff with the car he had rented and was returning. The plaintiff was apparently pinned between the two vehicles and suffered personal injuries as a result of the accident. The jury found that the defendant was negligent but only awarded $1 dollar in damages.
$780,833 Settlement (Pennsylvania 2020): A 25-year-old mother of two was killed when the defendant, driving an Enterprise rental car, struck a tractor trailer carrying hazardous chemicals. The lawsuit alleged that Enterprise was negligent for allowing its rental vehicle to be equipped with faulty rear tires.
Getting a Lawyer
Finally, you should contact an attorney. Negotiating with an insurance company is hard enough, so the addition of more and more parties can only make things more difficult. An experienced car accident attorney can determine whether you are at fault, meaning it is best to involve them as early as possible in the process.
The attorneys at Miller & Zois are experienced car accident litigators, who have navigated clients through the arduous process of making a claim. If you or a family member was involved in a rental car accident, call us at 800-553-8082 for a free case consultation.